Tuesday, July 31, 2012

The Results Are In: Mobil 1 Extended Perf. v. Pennzoil Ultra

Between planning a wedding, getting married, trying to finish up my PhD and find a job, life has been insanely hectic.  Hence, I have been almost entirely MIA since over a year ago.  However, in that time, I have been able to stay active with the car hobby and even begin autocrossing.  That's enough catch-up, now on to the main point of this post.

When we first purchased the TSX, I immediately did an oil change with Mobil 1 Extended Performance 5w-30 and the Mobil 1 M1-110 oil filter.  About 3000 miles later, I did another oil change with the same materials.  I realize that the service interval is 10,000 miles/1 year but I had no idea about the condition of the engine internals and wanted to rest easier knowing there was clean oil in there.  Around this time (Dec. 2010) I began seeing commercials for Pennzoil Ultra.  The commercials showed visual comparisons with Mobil 1 and always played up the "only motor oil exclusively recommended by Ferrari North America".  Their marketing was flawless and so I decided that the next oil change would be with Pennzoil Ultra.

Being the scientist that I am, I wanted to gather some empirical data of my own to verify Pennzoil's claim.  After running the Mobil 1 for 3,050 miles, I decided to do the oil change and send the used Mobil 1 off for analysis.  Analysis came back and everything looked good, including the recommendation to put more miles on each oil change.  So, the oil was changed with Pennzoil Ultra 5w-30 and I used the same Mobil 1 M1-110 oil filter.  However, I did not have the exact same driving conditions as with the Mobil 1.  First, I took the recommendation and decided to put exactly one year on the oil change, which ended up being 5,562 miles.  Furthermore, as mentioned above, I began autocross racing.  Therefore, the engine was abused A LOT more.  I sent the used Pennzoil Ultra off for analysis and the results are in.  You can take a look for yourself.
 Needless to say, I am quite impressed.  Of course, to validate the results many more data points must be taken but considering each data point takes one year to obtain, this is enough proof for me now.